thextreme1 wrote:This is quite the interesting topic and one Im sure every songwriter/ musician ponders now and then. I always make master copies in multiple formats and also make copies without lead vocals, just in case Im feeling that a performance wasnt all it could be or that time and repetition has added new nuances that make the song better. So I can just rerecord the lead vocals and not have to go back and redo everything. I also always make midi copies of each song, saving uncompressed versions of my audio recordings, so as not to have to go back and rerecord them.
I am a bit of a perfectionist when it comes to my music, so I usually make sure Im happy before I put a recording into the can. That way, Im not constantly going back and tweaking. If I do, that recording will never be finished.
When a song is done, leave it be and move on... otherwise you will spend the rest of your life trying to perfect the past and none of your time writing for your future. Which is the noose that usually hangs a lot of songwriters.
good post.
Your point about about finishing the song is equally true to keeping options open on a Song.
I don't go to the extreme of always perfecting the past. But I am improving my recording/mixing techniques over time. All my recording relies on the SEQ. I just recently leaned how to exceed 16 midi tracks without relying on more Audio.
Quality of Instrumentation is a big deal for me. sound programming is improving exponentially it seems. I might want to go back and revoice a horn section track.
A friend said a few of my tracks sound a little dry. So I might go back and add a little reverb. Little tweaks. Its not distracting to me. I have a file folder, of little tweak suggestions for my Songs. I can work, try them out at some point in the future.
I don't have a deep Song portfolio currently, about 20 . In a year, it will be 40 or 50 Songs. at that point, I will have reached a goal.
Other than adding a new trackI am 99% firm on the actual part performance.
Or the original theme. chord changes, song structure. Once I have captured the song message, style, etc, I am 99% satisfied.