Korg Forums

[jemkeys25]

I've noticed over the years that the best sounds, the ones that sounded the best through any speaker system, were the ones that i sampled from albums. now when an artist is finished recording thier album, and its just the way they want it, and it's bounced down to two track stereo its sent for the final step "MASTERING" this makes the recording air worthy, it gains the ability to sound good through any speaker system, were every sound sits in its proper place in a mix. Now from what i understand,not everyone can be a mastering egineer, that its a very skilled craft, so i propose that korg send some of its final samples to be mastered by a world class mastering egineer, and give the buyers of kronos a set of mastered sounds,kinda like we have a general midi set.

[peter_schwartz]

Interesting notion, but the mastering that takes place on a finished track is specifically tailored to that track. EQ, compression, brick wall limiting, multi-band limiting, sometimes aural exciting too, are all used on the final product (the 2-mix) not the individual sounds. So pre-mastering individual sounds without knowing what context they'll be used in kinda doesn't make sense. In short, you can't pre-master a track. You can only mix a track. Then it goes to mastering. Hope that makes sense.

[jemkeys25]

then you master each sound for a specific band set up. did you ever notice when listening to the radio, regardless of song that say the bass drum always sits in that sonic spot where all bass drums sit, and the bass,regardless of type of bass, sits in the bass spot, and pushes the right frequencies, and so on and on, the old saying "make every sound louder than the other. you could taylor the sounds to fit into a specific band mix.
a three piece, a four piece, and so on.

with 12 GB of samples it would be nice to have a portion of those samples mastered by a proffessional mastering engineer.
it couldn't hurt,
and you can master individual sounds, I hear songs all the time that start out just drums ,or just guitar or piano, and those sounds have been mastered and hold thier sonic integrity through any speaker system.

[Ajbbklyn]

One of the main ideas behind a workstation is that you can take a relatively raw sound source and tailor it (or mangle it) to your specific needs.

Why would you want a sound that's "pre-mastered" (a misnomer, actually - more accurate to say pre-equalized/compressed) to someone else's notion of how the source would/should optimally sound in a particular context? That would actually be more constraining than doing your own sound design - especially since we're talking about a board that has a full library of uncompressed samples.

I understand where you're coming from. It would be nice, in one sense, to have a library of "band-ready" sounds. But, I think that is something that is better left to the realm of the arranger keyboards - or to VSTi.
_________________
KORG Kronos2-61, Yamaha Motif ES6, KORG Minilogue, Farfisa VIP233, Axiom 49, BOSS RT-20, Neo Ventilator
andy-baum.com

[jemkeys25]

right, and you can still taylor the sounds the way you want, i'm only reffering to some of the sampled sounds which are,lets face it , just recordings of instruments over the range of the keyboard, so just like we have a general midi set, why not a mastered sample set, then we can have the best of both worlds.
I've done sequences that sounded great through a PA, but not so great plugged into the aux input of my stereo.

[X-Trade]

You can apply mastering with the total effects slot, and there are some effects which are fine for this.

The problem with 'mastered' samples is that they do not sound realistic. A piano playing a chord going through a compressor behaves differently to if each note were an already compressed sample, for example. Just like guitar chords distort differently to individual notes, so you can't really sample individual guitars.

Keyboards now and in the future will approach more realism by not having samples which are already processed, and applying processing using built in effects instead. Older keyboards did have heavily processed samples because effects processing on-board was much less available, as well as for assisting in the creation of consistent loop points, etc. So this really is the opposite direction that keyboards are going in, and for the better.

If you want to have a mastered sound, then you need to apply mastering yourself which suits your mix and arrangement. In Korg's latest workstations the total FX slot is ideal for this, and a master compressor or limiter will often provide a more consistent output level between combis or patches too.
_________________
Current Gear: Kronos 61, RADIAS-R, Volca Bass, ESX-1, microKorg, MS2000B, R3, Kaossilator Pro +, MiniKP, AX3000B, nanoKontrol, nanoPad MK II,
Other Mfgrs: Moog Sub37, Roland Boutique JX03, Novation MiniNova, Akai APC40, MOTU MIDI TimePiece 2, ART Pro VLA, Focusrite Saffire Pro 40.
Past Gear: Korg Karma, TR61, Poly800, EA-1, ER-1, ES-1, Kawai K1, Novation ReMote37SL, Boss GT-6B
Software: NI Komplete 10 Ultimate, Arturia V Collection, Ableton Live 9. Apple OSX El Capitan on 15" MacBook Pro

[peter_schwartz]

jem,

I think you're misunderstanding what how the mastering process works. As I mentioned in my post, you mix a track and you master a mix. You can't pre-master a mix by using samples that are somehow pre-mastered in the way you're suggesting. Even if it were possible to pre-master, say, a piano sound, whatever mastering techniques were applied might result in a sound that's too dynamic for a pop thing, great for jazz, just "OK" for a classical piece and totally wrong for a country track.

Even sample-heavy tracks, like rap tracks which use lots of samples of already mastered records have to be mastered.

To make an analogy, asking for "pre-mastered" samples is like buying house paint at random without looking at the color on the label. When you get home and open the can, the color might be perfect, or it might be "kinda OK", or possibly the most ugly color you've ever seen.

HTH,

PS

[jimknopf]

This is exactly the reason why I always want "raw" sounds, and NEVER processed ones.

I understand where the OP comes from, and how you (jemkeys25) would just like to have that compressed BIG sound ready for use, probably especially in electronica and hiphop or the like. But it wouldn't work, just because adding mastering can be done anytime, but getting heavy processing off of a sound afterwards and getting it rebuilt or changed in a convincing way is difficult up to impossible to achieve.

In my case you can add that I feel strong dislike and even contempt for many results of the well known "loudness wars" of the last two decades. I understand the value of compression and other processing for certain musical styles to a certain degree, but from some point onward it just sounds dreadful to me, and then I prefer any decent analog tape recording of the 70s over that.

[jemkeys25]

oh no, i disagree shwartz, any sound can be mastered weather its by itself or in a mix, if anyone can get proffesionally mastered results from an m3 or oasys or kronos, i'd like to hear it, and I want it to sound good through any speaker,even a clock radio.

again,I'm only asking for a mastered sample set, a small potion of the 12GB of samples.

[peter_schwartz]

[StephenKay]

I agree with Peter, or let me say "I echo" what he is saying, because there's nothing to agree or disagree on. Mastering is applied to a finished mix. Period. There's really no discussion.

Let's just, for a moment, go along with your way of looking at it - say you "mastered" a bunch of sounds individually. Once you put them together with each other, they would require different mastering as part of a full mix. Once you lay a lead vocal on top of them, they would require re-mastering in order to have the vocal be part of the mastering process and sit in the mix properly. And so on.

Mastering is applied as a final step to the whole mix. That's the definition of Mastering.
_________________
Stephen Kay - KARMA Developer • Karma-Lab - karma-lab.com

[Sina172]

...

[peter_schwartz]

[jemkeys25]

ok,so can you get proffessionally mastered results from an m3 or oasys or a kronos, or would I need external help?

[X-Trade]